1737 BAY STREET SARASOTA, FL 34236

update time: 03/13/2026 20:52:59

Investment or full time living, this beautiful and unique compound in the heart of Sarasota is just steps away from the downtown, hospital, shopping, and the bayfront is the coveted West of the Trail Hudson Bayou Neighborhood. This one a kind home with a separate art studio and studio apt in the back consists of a beautiful and cozy main house with 2 bdr, 2 baths, dining, updated kitchen with granite countertops and stainless steel appliances was designed and well loved by its owners, one a Ringling Art graduate and both longtime Sarasota residents, for a full time retreat over the past 15 years. Custom details such as ceramic tile, hardwood floors, with the main house completely replumbed just recently in 2025. In 2020, a second building was custom built in the back to allow for an art studio on the first level and regular stairs, as well as a custom-made spiral staircase lead you to a fantastic studio apt/"She Shed" on the second floor for guests and/or Air BNB possibilities in the future. Continue on and gather on the rooftop for views of the city and fireworks with a sneak peak of Hudson Bayou depending upon neighbor's foliage height. No flooding or damage from past hurricanes. This home remained high and dry and has been lovingly updated and maintained. Home and apt Air BNB vs seasonal rental potential. Rental income potential estimates available.

From downtown Sarasota Bayfront go north on US 41/Mound St. turn right (south) onto Osprey and next right onto Bay St. Home is halfway down dead-end street on the right.

Property Details

Nearby Properties

Single Family Residence Active

1821 LINCOLN DRIVE SARASOTA, FL 34236

4 Beds1/4Baths4,945sqft2026 built

$5,425,000.00

Single Family Residence Active

1749 LINCOLN PARK CIRCLE SARASOTA, FL 34236

4 Beds1/3Baths4,168sqft2001 built

$3,750,000.00

Townhouse Active

4911 N NEBRASKA AVENUE TAMPA, FL 33603

3 Beds1/3Baths2,663sqft2021 built

$575,000.00

Condominium Active

800 HUDSON AVENUE UNIT 106 SARASOTA, FL 34236

3 Beds0/3Baths1,706sqft1984 built

$625,000.00

Single Family Residence Active

660 OLD BARTOW LAKE WALES ROAD BARTOW, FL 33830

3 Beds0/2Baths3,244sqft2019 built

$889,000.00

Townhouse Active

1720 ALDERMAN STREET SARASOTA, FL 34236

3 Beds0/4Baths3,154sqft2024 built

$1,795,000.00

Single Family Residence Active

1621 BAY POINT COURT SARASOTA, FL 34236

4 Beds1/4Baths4,242sqft2025 built

$5,950,000.00

Condominium Active

862 HUDSON AVENUE UNIT 862 SARASOTA, FL 34236

3 Beds0/2Baths1,472sqft1989 built

$925,000.00

Condominium Active

858 HUDSON AVENUE UNIT 858 SARASOTA, FL 34236

3 Beds0/2Baths1,533sqft1989 built

$920,000.00

Single Family Residence Active

125 BURNS ROAD TERRA CEIA, FL 34250

4 Beds0/4Baths4,750sqft2020 built

$1,750,000.00

Single Family Residence Active

123 S WIGGINS ROAD PLANT CITY, FL 33566

4 Beds1/2Baths2,816sqft2007 built

$950,000.00

Condominium Active

6311 NEWTOWN CIRCLE UNIT 11B2 TAMPA, FL 33615

2 Beds1/2Baths1,260sqft1979 built

$155,000.00

Single Family Residence Active

1798 LINCOLN PARK CIRCLE SARASOTA, FL 34236

4 Beds1/2Baths5,193sqft2001 built

$2,950,000.00

Single Family Residence Active

146 4TH AVENUE NE UNIT 600 ST PETERSBURG, FL 33701

5 Beds1/6Baths7,457sqft2015 built

$7,950,000.00

Condominium Active

825 OSPREY AVENUE UNIT 108 SARASOTA, FL 34236

2 Beds0/2Baths1,520sqft1985 built

$495,000.00

Single Family Residence Active

5811 MARINER STREET TAMPA, FL 33609

5 Beds1/4Baths6,672sqft2017 built

$3,990,000.00

Single Family Residence Active

652 N JACKSON STREET EAGLE LAKE, FL 33839

2 Beds0/1Baths648sqft1957 built

$165,000.00

Condominium Active

3711 W IOWA AVENUE UNIT 214 TAMPA, FL 33611

2 Beds0/2Baths910sqft1990 built

$199,000.00

Condominium Active

6323 NEWTOWN CIRCLE UNIT 23A1 TAMPA, FL 33615

3 Beds1/2Baths2,012sqft1979 built

$159,000.00

Condominium Active

825 S OSPREY AVENUE UNIT 101 SARASOTA, FL 34236

2 Beds0/2Baths1,520sqft1985 built

$525,000.00